30 November 2025

Melmerby Mistletoe Slice Recipe

This recipe is from food writer and culinary crime novelist Orlando Murrin. His latest book being Murder Below Deck, which contains six 'killer' recipes and is out now in hardback, or in paperback in May available for preorder now.

We'll leave the rest to Orlando...

This recipe started off life as Melmerby Slice, created in honour of JM Hall’s Thirsk Garden Centre mystery series (the latest - a cracker – is A Brush With Death): it’s the sleuths’ teatime favourite. (NB Thirsk is about 15 minutes from Steenbergs central so a local author).

When I remembered that my favourite spice company was based in Melmerby, I couldn’t resist giving it a Christmas twist.

Note before you begin: after mixing the biscuit layer, don’t forget to weigh out 175g into a fresh bowl, as it’s used for the crumble. This is clearly explained in step 2, but speaking from experience, easily forgotten.
Cuts into 18 bars

FOR THE BISCUIT LAYER
350g plain flour
2 tsp mixed spice
pinch of salt
125g caster sugar
225g butter, room temperature
FOR THE FILLING
300g mincemeat
FOR THE CRUMBLE TOPPING
50g walnuts or flaked almonds, toasted and chopped
50g rolled or jumbo oats
50g light muscovado sugar
25g butter, room temperature
dusting of golden icing sugar, to finish

1 Line a traybake tin (about 13x9 inches) with baking paper or foil, folding it right into the edges, and butter lightly.
2 Put the flour, spice, salt and caster sugar into a bowl and mix. Add the 225g butter and rub in till sandy and beginning to clump. (If you prefer washing up to sticky fingers, you can do this is a processor or mixer.) Transfer 175g of this mixture to a bowl, to use as a base for the topping in step 4.
3 Tip the remaining flour mixture into the lined tin and use a spatula to spread it out evenly, then press down firmly all over. Put into the oven – no need to preheat unless you’re in a mad rush – turn it to 170C fan and bake for 20-25 minutes, rotating at half time, till just golden round the edges and on the point of browning.
4 Make the topping while the biscuit layer is in the oven. Mix the reserved flour mixture, nuts, oats and muscovado, then rub in the 25g butter until crumbly.
5 When the biscuit base comes out of the oven, spread thinly with mincemeat, right to the edges, then sprinkle over the crumble mixture and spread evenly with your fingers so the mincemeat is roughly covered. Put back in the oven for a further 20-25 minutes, rotating at half time, till the mixture is brown and the mincemeat gently hissing.
6 Allow to cool completely in the tin (two to three hours) then lift out and cut into slices. They keep for about 3 days in a plastic box, although they will start to soften; or you can freeze them. Sift over a little icing sugar before serving.

Don't forget to pre-order your book, mixes culinary recipes and tips with old fashioned sleuthing, another Paul Delamare mystery.